Beauty biology map

Photoaging & collagen degradation

Ultraviolet exposure drives reactive oxygen species formation, activates AP-1 and NF-kB signalling, and increases matrix metalloproteinase expression while reducing procollagen synthesis. The net result described in the literature is fragmented dermal collagen and elastin. UV filters remain the intervention with the strongest supporting evidence.

100%
Photoaging & collagen deg…COL1A1MMP1MMP9P4HA1LOXRARATP53Extracellular matrix orga…Degradation of the extrac…Collagen biosynthesis and…DNA damage response (UV-i…Collagen biosynthesisExtracellular matrix remo…UV photoprotection

drag to pan · hover to isolate a path · click a node for detail

IngredientMoleculeTargetGenePathwayProcessOutcome
Text alternative for this network
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with COL1A1high confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with MMP1high confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with MMP9medium confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with P4HA1high confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with LOXmedium confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with RARAhigh confidence
  • Photoaging & collagen degradation associated with TP53medium confidence
  • COL1A1 participates in Extracellular matrix organisationhigh confidence
  • MMP1 participates in Extracellular matrix organisationhigh confidence
  • MMP9 participates in Extracellular matrix organisationmedium confidence
  • P4HA1 participates in Extracellular matrix organisationhigh confidence
  • LOX participates in Extracellular matrix organisationmedium confidence
  • RARA participates in Extracellular matrix organisationhigh confidence
  • TP53 participates in Extracellular matrix organisationmedium confidence
  • COL1A1 participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixhigh confidence
  • MMP1 participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixhigh confidence
  • MMP9 participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixmedium confidence
  • P4HA1 participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixhigh confidence
  • LOX participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixmedium confidence
  • RARA participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixhigh confidence
  • TP53 participates in Degradation of the extracellular matrixmedium confidence
  • COL1A1 participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymeshigh confidence
  • MMP1 participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymeshigh confidence
  • MMP9 participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymesmedium confidence
  • P4HA1 participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymeshigh confidence
  • LOX participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymesmedium confidence
  • RARA participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymeshigh confidence
  • TP53 participates in Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymesmedium confidence
  • COL1A1 participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • MMP1 participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • MMP9 participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • P4HA1 participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • LOX participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • RARA participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • TP53 participates in DNA damage response (UV-induced)medium confidence
  • Extracellular matrix organisation associated with Collagen biosynthesishigh confidence
  • Degradation of the extracellular matrix associated with Collagen biosynthesishigh confidence
  • Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymes associated with Collagen biosynthesishigh confidence
  • DNA damage response (UV-induced) associated with Collagen biosynthesismedium confidence
  • Extracellular matrix organisation associated with Extracellular matrix remodellinghigh confidence
  • Degradation of the extracellular matrix associated with Extracellular matrix remodellinghigh confidence
  • Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymes associated with Extracellular matrix remodellinghigh confidence
  • DNA damage response (UV-induced) associated with Extracellular matrix remodellingmedium confidence
  • Extracellular matrix organisation associated with UV photoprotectionhigh confidence
  • Degradation of the extracellular matrix associated with UV photoprotectionhigh confidence
  • Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymes associated with UV photoprotectionhigh confidence
  • DNA damage response (UV-induced) associated with UV photoprotectionmedium confidence

Genes & proteins

  • COL1A1high confidence

    Collagen type I alpha 1 chain

  • MMP1high confidence

    Matrix metallopeptidase 1

  • MMP9medium confidence

    Matrix metallopeptidase 9

  • P4HA1high confidence

    Prolyl 4-hydroxylase subunit alpha 1

  • LOXmedium confidence

    Lysyl oxidase

  • RARAhigh confidence

    Retinoic acid receptor alpha

  • TP53medium confidence

    Tumor protein p53

Pathways

  • Extracellular matrix organisation

    high confidence

    Assembly and maintenance of dermal matrix.

    Reactome R-HSA-1474244

  • Degradation of the extracellular matrix

    high confidence

    Matrix metalloproteinase-driven collagen fragmentation.

    Reactome R-HSA-1474228

  • Collagen biosynthesis and modifying enzymes

    high confidence

    Hydroxylation and crosslinking of procollagen.

    Reactome R-HSA-1650814

  • DNA damage response (UV-induced)

    medium confidence

    Photolesion recognition and repair signalling.

    Reactome R-HSA-73893

Ingredients studied here

Processes

  • Collagen biosynthesis — Dermis
  • Extracellular matrix remodelling — Dermis
  • UV photoprotection — Stratum corneum

Research on this topic

ReviewCosmetics (review) · 2021

Cosmetic retinoid esters: an assessment of available public evidence

Notes that public independent data on hydroxypinacolone retinoate are limited relative to retinol and retinoic acid.

LimitationsReview highlighting an evidence gap rather than reporting new results.

Randomised controlled trialBritish Journal of Dermatology · 2019n = 44

Prospective randomized double-blind assessment of topical bakuchiol and retinol for facial photoaging

Reported comparable improvement in wrinkle and pigmentation scores between bakuchiol and retinol, with less scaling and stinging reported for bakuchiol.

LimitationsSingle centre, 12 weeks, no vehicle arm, so both may reflect regression to the mean.

PMID 29752709Bakuchiol · Retinol
ReviewJournal of Investigative Dermatology (review) · 2015

Retinoic acid receptor expression and retinoid signalling in human skin

Summarises RAR/RXR heterodimer signalling as the transcriptional mechanism of retinoid action in epidermis and dermis.

LimitationsNarrative review; mechanistic focus without effect-size synthesis.

Identifier not curated — search Europe PMCRetinol · All-trans retinoic acid · Retinaldehyde
ReviewOxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity (review) · 2015

GHK peptide in tissue remodelling and gene expression

Summarises reported effects of GHK and GHK-Cu on matrix protein and antioxidant gene expression in cell and animal models.

LimitationsReview with substantial single-group authorship; human cosmetic endpoints sparse.

Identifier not curated — search Europe PMCCopper tripeptide-1 · GHK tripeptide · Palmitoyl tripeptide-1
Randomised controlled trialJournal of Cosmetic Dermatology · 2013n = 62

A randomised trial of a pentapeptide-containing moisturiser for periorbital wrinkles

Reported small improvements in wrinkle depth versus vehicle, with overlapping confidence intervals on several endpoints.

LimitationsSmall effect size; identifier not verified; peptide not isolated from other actives in the formulation.

Randomised controlled trialAnnals of Internal Medicine · 2013n = 903

Daily sunscreen use and skin ageing: a randomised trial

Reported no detectable increase in skin ageing over 4.5 years in the daily sunscreen group compared with discretionary use.

LimitationsSunscreen formulation was not zinc-oxide-specific; outcome assessed by microtopography of the hand.

PMID 23732711Zinc oxide
In-vitroInternational Journal of Cosmetic Science · 2012

Stability and skin delivery of ascorbyl phosphate derivatives

Reported improved formulation stability for magnesium ascorbyl phosphate but slower and variable conversion to free ascorbate in skin models.

LimitationsFormulation and ex-vivo delivery only; no clinical endpoints.

Identifier not curated — search Europe PMCMagnesium ascorbyl phosphate · L-Ascorbic acid
In-vitroPhotochemistry and Photobiology · 2011

Green tea polyphenols and UV-induced matrix metalloproteinase expression in human skin models

Reported reduced UV-induced MMP-9 expression in treated skin equivalents.

LimitationsSkin equivalent model; identifier not verified; human endpoints lacking.

AnimalJournal of Ethnopharmacology · 2010

Centella asiatica triterpenes and wound-related collagen deposition

Reported increased collagen deposition and faster wound closure in a rodent model.

LimitationsAnimal wound model; not equivalent to intact cosmetic use; identifier not verified.

Randomised controlled trialArchives of Dermatology · 2007n = 36

Retinol improves the appearance of naturally aged skin

Reported improvement in fine wrinkling with topical retinol versus vehicle in older adults.

LimitationsSmall sample; older cohort limits generalisation; identifier not verified during curation.

HumanDermatologic Surgery · 2005n = 50

Niacinamide: a B vitamin that improves aging facial skin appearance

Reported improvements in several appearance endpoints including fine lines and skin texture over 12 weeks of use versus vehicle.

LimitationsManufacturer-affiliated authorship; appearance endpoints partly investigator-graded.

PMID 16029679Niacinamide
HumanJournal of Investigative Dermatology · 2005n = 9

Ferulic acid stabilises a solution of vitamins C and E and doubles its photoprotection

Reported improved formulation stability and increased measured photoprotection for a C/E/ferulic combination on human skin.

LimitationsVery small sample; surrogate photoprotection endpoints; industry-affiliated.

PMID 16297196Ferulic acid · L-Ascorbic acid · Tocopherol
In-vitroInternational Journal of Cosmetic Science · 2005

Palmitoyl pentapeptide and procollagen synthesis in fibroblast culture

Reported increased collagen I and fibronectin expression in treated fibroblast cultures.

LimitationsIn-vitro; identifier not verified; no dermal delivery data.

Randomised controlled trialBritish Journal of Dermatology · 2003n = 33

Alpha-lipoic acid cream and photoaged facial skin: a randomised controlled trial

Reported modest improvement in photoaging scores versus vehicle on half-face assessment.

LimitationsSmall sample; identifier not verified; subjective grading.

Randomised controlled trialDermatologic Surgery · 2002n = 19

Topical vitamin C and photoaging: a double-blind half-face study

Reported improvement in investigator-assessed photoaging scores on the vitamin C treated side.

LimitationsVery small sample; identifier not verified during curation; formulation stability not reported.

In-vitroInternational Journal of Cosmetic Science · 2002

Acetyl hexapeptide-8 and SNARE complex assembly in vitro

Reported interference with SNAP-25 dependent complex formation in a cell-free system.

LimitationsCell-free system; cutaneous penetration to neuromuscular junctions not demonstrated.

HumanJournal of Clinical Investigation · 2000n = 22

Retinoid-induced procollagen synthesis and matrix metalloproteinase suppression in human skin in vivo

Reported increased procollagen I expression and reduced MMP-1 in biopsied retinoid-treated skin.

LimitationsBiopsy-based surrogate endpoints; identifier not verified during curation.

Identifier not curated — search Europe PMCAll-trans retinoic acid · Retinol
ReviewAmerican Journal of Clinical Nutrition (review) · 1991

Ascorbate requirement for hydroxylation and secretion of procollagen

Establishes ascorbate as an obligatory cofactor for prolyl and lysyl hydroxylases in collagen maturation.

LimitationsNutritional/biochemical focus rather than topical cosmetic use.

Identifier not curated — search Europe PMCL-Ascorbic acid · Magnesium ascorbyl phosphate
Randomised controlled trialJAMA · 1988n = 30

Topical tretinoin improves photoaged skin: a double-blind vehicle-controlled study

Reported statistically significant improvement in photoaging endpoints with tretinoin versus vehicle.

LimitationsSmall sample; prescription-strength retinoid, not a cosmetic retinol.

PMID 3336176All-trans retinoic acid

Community evidence

Submitted by readers

Submit a study

Reader submissions appear here only after review. They are not part of the curated dataset and do not affect the Skinceptor Evidence Index.

No approved community submissions yet.

Sources